I was the one who did the research into the bridge volumes, based on 2006 volumes that are easily accessible on mndots website. Ive been pleasantly surprised at the amount of blog activity this has generated. Minneapolis wcco friday marks seven years since the i35w bridge in minneapolis collapsed, killing people and injuring 145 others. Collapsed a survivors climb from the wreckage of the i35w bridge garrett ebling on. The interstate highway bridge i35w over the mississippi river in minneapolis, minnesota, collapsed suddenly at 6. The interstate 35w bridge over the mississippi river collapsed this evening, plunging dozens of vehicles into the water, killing seven people and injuring more than 60. Kimberly brown was among the survivors when the i35w bridge collapsed in. People and vehicles fell into the water, onto the river banks, and onto the. Failure in structural steels and overview of i35w bridge collapse jack przywara, university of notre dame advisor.
Lessons learned from the 35w bridge collapse the current. The bridge was owned by the federal government, and was operated and maintained by the state of minnesota. The collapse of bridge i 35w in minnesota during the rush hour of august 1put tremendous pressure on the reliability and safety of our bridges nationwide. The investigation into the cause of the disaster took 16 months, with the final report being published on december 19, 2008. What is the legacy of the 35w bridge collapse on minnesota. Rybaks office said monday that no public event is planned for this aug. With a solid, creative cause mapping facilitation, the organizations involved could collect an incredibly high number of potential solutions.
It means they must be monitored, inspected and maintained. Aug 02, 2007 thats not a problem thats likely to cause collapse, but the type that is likely to cause collapse is the rusting of the main members of the bridge, the truss members that were supporting the. When the bridge collapsed, more than 191 tons of construction. Collapsed a survivors climb from the wreckage of the i35w bridge. The 1,907footlong, eightlane i35w highway bridge that was constructed over the mississippi river in minneapolis, minnesota, meet a disastrous breakdown in the core span of the deck truss. Faulty design led to minnesota bridge collapse, inquiry finds. On one particular blog a person argues that my view is inconsistent with the book of job. My thoughts after reading a book by 35w bridge collapse. Minneapolis bridge had passed inspections the new york times. Failure in structural steels and overview of i35w bridge. Questions about the cause of the collapse and whether it could have. In addition to sharing the emotions experienced by the public, structural engineering experts, including the authors of this essay, were perplexed.
This is probably an hour or 2 after the collapse, taken from the university avenue. So what, if anything, is the legacy of the bridge collapse on minnesota politics and policy. Jul 29, 2017 the day a bridge collapsed in minneapolis and lives changed forever. The state of minnesota has embarked on its own investigation. A new book examines the i35w bridge collapse, 11 years. Collapsed a survivors climb from the wreckage of the i. I35w bridge collapse and response minneapolis, minnesota august 1, 2007. On my august 9th blog, i argued that theres no reason to suppose that god was involved in the collapse of the 35 w bridge. On the day of the collapse, roadway work was underway on the i35w bridge, and four of the eight travel lanes two outside lanes northbound and two inside lanes southbound were closed to traffic. Ntsbs investigation revealed that the failure of the undersized u10 gusset plate initiated the bridges collapse. Both the point pleasant and the minneapolis i35w bridge had three spans that all fell together. Investigators say it has already yielded answers into.
Im going north, and we get right on the interstate. For example, a flood that damages bridge piers might not have caused a collapse except for a design flaw and poor maintenance. Minneapolis interstate 35w bridge collapse minnesota issues. I35 bridge collapse analysis writing down goals is a key starting point for any root cause analysis. This report presents a thorough research on i35 bridge collapse in minneapolis in 2007. Considered one of the worst 10 bridge collapse events in u. I35 bridge collapse thinkreliability, case studies. Nov 25, 2018 executive summary this report presents a thorough research on i35 bridge collapse in minneapolis in 2007. A new book examines the i35w bridge collapse, 11 years later.
The ntsb cited a design flaw as the likely cause of the collapse, noting that a toothin gusset plate ripped along a line of rivets, and. Mead cars in the mississippi river after the interstate 35w bridge collapsed wednesday, aug. A survivors account of americas crumbling infrastructure. This is report 166 of investigation and analysis of major fire incidents. Aug 02, 2007 heres a quote in 2005, according to secretary of transportation mary peters, the i 35w bridge scored a 50 out of 120 rating in a federal highway inspection of structural integrity, which marked. Faulty design led to minnesota bridge collapse, inquiry finds the. The top three bridges, in order, were the i94 bridge at 157,000 that 167,000 figure is actually 2004 counts, the i694 bridge at 150,000, then the i35w bridge at 140,000. It took just seconds for the 1,900 foot long structure to fall 116 feet, taking with it 84 cars, 200 motorists, and several construction workers. This note briefly summarizes an analysis based on original design drawings, an investigation of material evidence provided by the national transportation safety board ntsb, and a fullscale load rating of the bridge superstructure. Three investigations search for cause of i35w bridge collapse. Heres a quote in 2005, according to secretary of transportation mary peters, the i35w bridge scored a 50 out of 120 rating in a federal highway inspection of. Example to explain the sequence to cause weldedjoint toe crack, which is uncommon for modern inhouse fabricated.
The cause of the bridge collapse roberto ballarini. Remove one of those factors and the bridge may have remained upright. The memorial is located off west river parkway, in minneapolis. Mar 28, 2020 the busy interstate 35w bridge over the mississippi river in downtown minneapolis, minnesota, collapsed at the peak of rush hour on wednesday, august 1, 2007. At the same time it gave dent to our structural designers ability to come up. Faulty design led to minnesota bridge collapse, inquiry. Corley says hes been hired to investigate the 35w bridge collapse. The cases were handled via a novel consortium of legal entities that worked on a probono basis. I35w bridge collapse survivor writes riveting memoir.
We invited readers to write their own fragment about the 35w bridge, and many of you took us up on the offer. Friday marks 7 years since i35w bridge collapse wcco cbs. As we go through this list of 10 reasons why bridges collapse, keep in mind that most bridge collapses are the result of multiple factors. There was no known failure in the actual materials of the i 35w bridge many other factors played into the failure, but. These photos represent pre collapse and post collapse views of the area where the ntsb is focusing their investigation efforts. Both the point pleasant and the minneapolis i 35w bridge had three spans that all fell together. Jan 15, 2008 the i35w bridge was of a type called fracture critical, meaning that the failure of any major member would cause a collapse, because it had no redundancy. The i35w mississippi river bridge was an eightlane, steel truss arch bridge that carried. The ntsb cited a design flaw as the likely cause of the collapse, noting that a toothin gusset plate ripped along a line of rivets, and additional weight on the bridge at the time contributed to the catastrophic failure. It was 580m long, carried eight lanes of traffic four northbound and four southbound, and comprised 11 approach spans and three truss spans. New exhibit southwest minneapolis, mn a bridge piece commemorating the 10th anniversary will go on exhibit at the mill city museum july 28 to aug. The 35w bridge remembrance garden is a memorial commemorating the victims and survivors of the i35w bridge collapse. Shortly after 6 pm, the i35w bridge collapses with 111 motor vehicles. It introduces the topic and points to sources for further research.
The photo above is the i 35w bridge taken in november of 2006, about 8 months before the collapse. The photo below was taken about 3 weeks after the disaster. Economic impacts of the i35w bridge collapse he i35w mississippi river bridge provided direct access to downtown minneapolis, the university of minnesota, area businesses and north suburban destinations for more than 140,000 vehicles each day. Timeline internet resources articles books and reports. As of summer 2008, the cause of the i35w bridge collapse remains under investigation, and the final reports have yet to be written. Garretts book shows, in very personal ways via the stories of survivors lindsey, kim that bus driver, paula, omar, erica and others, the individuals behind the 35w bridge collapse. There was no known failure in the actual materials of the i35w bridge many other factors played into the failure, but. And so, by implication, god, not satan, was the ultimate cause of the 35 w bridge collapse. The memorial was revealed to the public on august 1, 2011, the fouryear anniversary of the collapse. Fire administrations regular examination of fires and other disasters in an. Federal regulators said support plates that were about half as thick as they should have been were the likely cause of the august 1, 2007, bridge collapse in minnesota that killed people and. Root cause analysis solutions for the i35 bridge collapse. Minneapolis i35w bridge collapse failure case studies.
The cause of the interstate 35w bridge failure on wednesday will probably become clear through metallurgical examinations of the wreckage, experts said, but recovering the metal parts will be. The 35w bridge remembrance garden is a memorial commemorating the victims and survivors of the i 35w bridge collapse. The 1,907footlong, eightlane i 35w highway bridge that was constructed over the mississippi river in minneapolis, minnesota, meet a disastrous breakdown in the core span of the deck truss. From there, the key is to ask why something happened and we can trace the incidents causes to create a cause map, an extremely effective root cause analysis tool. The day a bridge collapsed in minneapolis and lives. The collapsed 35w bridge in minneapolis seen on august 2, 2007. The fact that a bridge is deficient does not imply that it is likely to collapse or that it is unsafe. There were several astonishing things about this interviewnot unusual for religious talk shows on public radio, but astonishing still 1. Response to rabbi kushner on the collapse of the 35w bridge. A helicopter moves over the scene of the bridge collapse. The i35w bridge collapse university of nebraska press.
I35w bridge collapse and response, is part of the u. The day a bridge collapsed in minneapolis and lives changed. Aug 01, 2017 remembering the i 35w bridge collapse 10 years later the i 35w bridge was one of minnesotas busiest, carrying 140,000 cars a day over the mississippi river. The busy interstate 35w bridge over the mississippi river in downtown minneapolis, minnesota, collapsed at the peak of rush hour on wednesday, august 1, 2007. Kushner is best known for his book when bad things happen to good people. The bridge collapse tested the areas ability to handle a complicated mix of tactical and strategic problems effectively. The bridges gusset plates, which connect the steel beams, were too thin and had been further stressed by the presence of nearly 300 tons of construction equipment and materials that had been stored on the bridge deck for ongoing repair work. Her new book details her experience healing from injuries sustained in. A bridge shouldnt just fall down, senator amy klobuchar said after the august 1, 2007, collapse of the minneapolis i 35w eightlane steel truss bridge, which killed motorists, injured 145, and left a collective wound on the citys psyche and infrastructure. Nov 14, 2008 federal regulators said support plates that were about half as thick as they should have been were the likely cause of the august 1, 2007, bridge collapse in minnesota that killed people and. A bridge shouldnt just fall down, senator amy klobuchar said after the august 1, 2007, collapse of the minneapolis i35w eightlane steel truss bridge, which killed motorists, injured 145, and left a collective wound on the citys psyche and infrastructure. Her new book details her experience healing from injuries sustained in the collapse, and her own. Collapsed a survivors climb from the wreckage of the i35w.
The interstate 35w bridge was one of the busiest in minnesota before it fell aug. Kimberly brown was among the survivors when the i 35w bridge collapsed in minneapolis 11 years ago. I35w bridge collapse journal of bridge engineering vol. The 35w bridge collapse how a broken bridge brought us home. The agency is still talking with motorists who were on the bridge when it collapsed aug. What could have caused this very common bridge to collapse within a matter of seconds.
The day a bridge collapsed in minneapolis and lives changed forever. The i35w bridge was of a type called fracture critical, meaning that the failure of any major member would cause a collapse, because it had no redundancy. Structurally deficient means there are elements of the bridge that need to be monitored andor repaired. Brown weaves in tales about her quest to learn the real reason the bridge fell. I35w bridge collapse bridge collapse investigation focus area. Kapil khandelwal, university of notre dame introduction research into the study of the collapse of steel bridges has become popular with the recent i35w bridge collapse in minneapolis, minnesota. Finding more causes of those fatalities may allow us to solve the issues that caused them. Americas failing infrastructure and the way forward, said not faulting mndot was inexcusable. Brown was in shock minutes after the car she was in plunged 114 feet into the mississippi river after the interstate 35w bridge collapsed aug. Kimberly brown was among the survivors when the i35w bridge collapsed in minneapolis 11 years ago. Aug 03, 2012 we invited readers to write their own fragment about the 35w bridge, and many of you took us up on the offer. On august 1, 2007, the interstate 35w bridge in minneapolis collapsed beneath more than 140 commuters into the mississippi river in a cloud of dust, smoke, and flame during the evening rush hour. Countless investigations and precautionary measures were done to make all bridges pass standard procedures and render it safe for both the vehicles and passengers.
Aug 01, 2018 kimberly brown was among the survivors when the i 35w bridge collapsed in minneapolis 11 years ago. Oct 16, 2019 kelly kahle i35w bridge collapse survivor. Thats not a problem thats likely to cause collapse, but the type that is likely to cause collapse is the rusting of the main members of the bridge, the truss members that were supporting the. I35 bridge collapse in minneapolis research paper readessay. The busy interstate highway i35w bridge near downtown minneapolis collapsed into the mississippi river just after 6. Approximately 1,000 ft of the 1,907ftlong bridge fell to the water and ground, resulting in fatalities and 145. Mndot has hired wiss, janney, elstner associates to study the disaster. The 35w bridge collapse how a broken bridge brought us home the tragic collapse of the 35w bridge in minneapolis showed just what it means to be a minnesotan and affirmed this writers decision to make minnesota her home.
The 35w bridge collapse and the book of job greg boyd. In fact, the minneapolis bridge was completed just a few months before the point pleasant bridge failure. This is probably an hour or 2 after the collapse, taken from the university avenue bridge over the 35w freeway. Remembering the i35w bridge collapse 10 years later the i35w bridge was one of minnesotas busiest, carrying 140,000 cars a day over the mississippi river. This comprehensive electronic book on cdrom provides an uptodate collection of reference sources on the tragic collapse of the 5w bridge over. New i 35w bridge wins national design honor the new interstate 35w bridge over the mississippi river has been named a project of the year by the. Hence this blogger concludes that god, not satan, was the ultimate cause of jobs sufferings. I35w bridge collapse journal of bridge engineering vol 15, no 5. The 35w bridge collapse and the book of job greg boyd reknew. Tim pawlenty a potential republican presidential contender in 2012 addresses the 2007 collapse of the i35w bridge in. Minneapolis interstate 35w bridge collapse minnesota. The i 35w bridge over the mississippi river in minneapolis, minnesota, collapsed suddenly on august 1, 2007. Remembering the i35w bridge collapse 10 years later.
Tim pawlenty writes that ntsb ruled minneapolis bridge. After the collapse, the bridge was lodged in the river where, under minnesota statute, the hennepin county. Ill briefly make four points from the book of job against this argument. This guide is compiled by staff at the minnesota legislative reference library on a topic of interest to state legislators. Working theory blames design, weight for i35w bridge. As of summer 2008, the cause of the i 35w bridge collapse remains under investigation, and the final reports have yet to be written. Minneapolis, minnesota august 23, 2010 today attorneys representing the victims of the august 1, 2007 i35w bridge collapse announced that a final settlement was reached in the lawsuit against urs corporation, the international engineering firm which had responsibility for inspecting the i35w bridge before its collapse. Cars sit on remains of the interstate 35w bridge after it collapsed during. The interstate 35w bridge was one of the busiest in minnesota. From 11 to 12 this morning, gary eichten of minnesota public radio interviewed rabbi harold kushner about the collapse of the 35w bridge. That enables the reader to connect in a world where disasters are often lumped into numbers and places and quickly forgotten when the next disaster occurs. Three investigations search for cause of i35w bridge collapse the national transportation safety board isnt the only entity looking for the cause of the bridge collapse. Jul 09, 2012 collapsed a survivors climb from the wreckage of the i35w bridge garrett ebling on. Collapse of i35w highway bridge minneapolis, minnesota.
1071 1398 862 81 978 158 46 1080 1 1084 243 297 784 169 509 827 152 460 855 342 409 340 712 383 540 1386 1040 842 361 310 46 297 591 319 1149 437